Introduction
Craving the best pizza in Fort Collins? Whether you’re a student at CSU, a longtime local, or just passing through, Fort Collins has become a hub for diverse, mouthwatering pizza options. From wood-fired ovens and New York-style thin crust to deep-dish comfort, the city serves up some of the best pies in Colorado. In this guide, we rank the 10 best pizza spots in Fort Collins, based on flavor, atmosphere, price, and local buzz.
Table of Contents
How We Ranked These Spots
When it comes to ranking the best pizza in Fort Collins, it’s not just about taste (though that’s obviously key). We looked at a few major factors:
- Flavor and ingredient quality
- Crust style and baking method
- Atmosphere and service
- Price-to-portion value
- Local reputation and reviews
These spots aren’t sponsored — they earned their place with great food and authentic vibes. This isn’t just a random list—it’s your roadmap to the best pizza in Fort Collins, handpicked by locals.
1. Krazy Karl’s Pizza
Best For: Late-night cravings and unconventional topping combos
Located near CSU, Krazy Karl’s is practically a rite of passage for locals. Known for its cream cheese base pies and massive slices, it’s wildly popular for a reason. You can’t go wrong with their “Cream Cheese Pepperoni” or their loaded “Twisted Sister.” It’s a local favorite that consistently ranks for best pizza in Fort Collins.
- Address: 1124 W Elizabeth St, Fort Collins, CO
- Price: $$
- Atmosphere: Casual, student-friendly, loud in the best way
- Must-try: Cream Cheese Jalapeño pizza
Images may be AI-generated and do not necessarily reflect the actual food from the reviewed establishment
2. Otto Pint
Best For: Outdoor patio + craft beer pairing
Tucked off College Ave, Otto Pint delivers wood-fired pizza with gourmet twists. Their brick oven gives the crust a perfect char, and the toppings range from roasted garlic to prosciutto and fig. Bonus: They have a rotating list of local beers on tap. Otto Pint is often mentioned in lists of the best pizza places in Fort Collins.
- Address: 1100 Oakridge Dr, Fort Collins, CO
- Price: $$$
- Atmosphere: Trendy but relaxed
- Must-try: Prosciutto + arugula + balsamic glaze pie
Images may be AI-generated and do not necessarily reflect the actual food from the reviewed establishment
3. Pizza Casbah
Best For: Giant New York-style slices
A staple in Fort Collins for decades, Pizza Casbah brings NYC flavor west. Expect slices bigger than your face and unapologetically greasy cheese perfection. It’s open late and delivers, making it a college-town hero. Many locals argue Casbah serves the best pizza in Fort Collins new york style.
- Address: 126 W Laurel St, Fort Collins, CO
- Price: $
- Atmosphere: Classic hole-in-the-wall
- Must-try: Casbah Supreme slice
Images may be AI-generated and do not necessarily reflect the actual food from the reviewed establishment
4. Slyce Pizza Co.
Best For: Funky toppings and downtown nightlife
Located in the heart of Old Town, Slyce Pizza Co. is a staple for late-night foodies and anyone who wants to get experimental with their slices. They offer pizza by the slice with rotating, bold flavor combos like Mac N’ Cheese, Buffalo Chicken, and even Vegan BBQ.
- Address: 163 W Mountain Ave, Fort Collins, CO
- Price: $$
- Atmosphere: Lively, artsy, popular with night owls
- Must-try: Mac N’ Cheese slice
Images may be AI-generated and do not necessarily reflect the actual food from the reviewed establishment.
5. Panhandler’s Pizza
Best For: Deep-dish lovers
You either love deep dish or you don’t — and Panhandler’s will convert the skeptics. With a buttery crust and layers of cheese so thick you’ll need a knife, it’s Fort Collins’ go-to for heavy, satisfying pies. A must-visit spot for anyone hunting for the best pizza in Fort Collins deep dish style.
- Address: 2721 S College Ave, Fort Collins, CO
- Price: $$$
- Atmosphere: Casual diner vibe
- Must-try: Classic Chicago-style deep dish
Images may be AI-generated and do not necessarily reflect the actual food from the reviewed establishment
6. Mama Roni’s
Best For: Budget-friendly family takeout
One of Fort Collins’ oldest delivery pizza joints, Mama Roni’s offers solid pizza at great prices. It’s not gourmet, but it’s reliable and fast. Their online ordering and coupons make them a go-to for busy families. While not the most high-end, Mama Roni’s often appears in best pizza in Fort Collins conversations for its convenience and value.
- Address: Multiple locations in Fort Collins
- Price: $
- Atmosphere: Takeout-centric
- Must-try: Pepperoni + Mushroom combo
Images may be AI-generated and do not necessarily reflect the actual food from the reviewed establishment
7. D.P. Dough
Best For: Late-night calzones and college comfort food
D.P. Dough might not be traditional pizza, but their hot, overstuffed calzones pack all the flavor of a top-tier pie. It’s a favorite among CSU students, especially for late-night cravings. Their menu is creative and enormous. D.P. Dough may not be traditional, but it’s earned a spot on the best pizza in Fort Collins list.
- Address: 1205 W Elizabeth St, Fort Collins, CO
- Price: $
- Atmosphere: Takeout/delivery focused
- Must-try: Roni Zoni (pepperoni, mozzarella, ricotta)
Images may be AI-generated and do not necessarily reflect the actual food from the reviewed establishment.
8. Beaujolais Bistro Pizza Nights
Best For: Upscale French-Italian fusion pizza
On select nights, Beaujolais Bistro — known for French cuisine — offers artisan pizza from a wood-fired oven. If you like an upscale pie joint yo might argue this is the best pizza in Fort Collins. These aren’t your average pies; they’re thin, elegant, and flavor-packed with ingredients like chèvre, caramelized onion, and smoked pancetta.
- Address: 123 N College Ave, Fort Collins, CO
- Price: $$$
- Atmosphere: Upscale, wine-bar ambiance
- Must-try: Goat Cheese + Onion + Arugula pizza
Images may be AI-generated and do not necessarily reflect the actual food from the reviewed establishment.
9. Totally 80’s Pizza
Best For: Retro vibes and pop culture fanatics
Totally 80’s Pizza isn’t just a place to grab a slice—it’s a full-blown throwback experience. With walls covered in vintage memorabilia, classic arcade games, and a soundtrack that’ll transport you to the neon era, the pizza is only part of the show. But don’t be fooled—their pies are legit, with crispy crusts, rich sauce, and creative topping combos.
- Address: 2567 S Shields St, Fort Collins, CO
- Price: $$
- Atmosphere: Nostalgic, quirky, and family-friendly
- Must-try: The “Ghostbuster” — loaded with spicy sausage, green peppers, and a swirl of ranch
Images may be AI-generated and do not necessarily reflect the actual food from the reviewed establishment.
10. Pulcinella Pizzeria
Best in Fort Collins for: Authentic Neapolitan pizza and imported ingredients
Pulcinella brings traditional Neapolitan pizza to Fort Collins using imported flour, San Marzano tomatoes, and wood-fired ovens. Their crust is soft, slightly charred, and blistered to perfection — true to its Naples roots. Even though this authentic spot is number 10 on the list most locals would agree its the best pizza in Fort Collins.
- Address: 1119 W Drake Rd C12, Fort Collins, CO 80526
- Price: $$$
- Atmosphere: Intimate, authentic Italian
- Must-try: Margherita D.O.C. with buffalo mozzarella and fresh basil
Images may be AI-generated and do not necessarily reflect the actual food from the reviewed establishment.
What is the best pizza place in Fort Collins for late-night food?
Krazy Karl’s Pizza and D.P. Dough are top choices for late-night eats. Krazy Karl’s serves massive slices with unique toppings, while D.P. Dough offers calzones until the early hours.
Where can I find wood-fired pizza in Fort Collins?
Otto Pint and Beaujolais Bistro offer delicious wood-fired pizzas. Otto Pint focuses on craft-beer pairings, and Beaujolais serves upscale French-Italian fusion pies on select nights.
Is there deep dish pizza in Fort Collins?
Yes, Panhandler’s Pizza is the go-to spot for deep dish in Fort Collins. Their buttery crust and layers of cheese make it a local favorite.
What’s the most affordable pizza in Fort Collins?
Mama Roni’s and Pizza Casbah offer budget-friendly options. Casbah’s slices are huge, and Mama Roni’s is perfect for takeout and family meals.
Are there any custom-build pizza places in Fort Collins?
Pulcinella Pizzeria is the best option for build-your-own pizza. You can customize every part—from crust to toppings—and it’s cooked fast in a brick oven.
Ready to explore the pizza scene yourself? These ten spots are just the beginning of what Fort Collins has to offer — but they’re the cream of the crop. Whether you want late-night comfort or upscale artisanal pies, this list is your go-to guide for the best pizza in Fort Collins.
We’re always on the hunt for new flavors. If you think we missed a must-try pizza joint in Fort Collins, let us know! Mention us on socials @ColoradoFoodReviews or shoot a message through our contact page.
Want more deep dives like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and check out our full reviews of green chili in Fort Collins and hidden breakfast gems in Estes Park.
About the Author
David Lanketh grew up dodging belt-buckle breakfasts and grease-slick tamales in the alleyways of Pueblo. Food wasn’t fancy—it was survival, storytelling, and sometimes, salvation. Now 48 and deeply rooted in Colorado’s local food scene, David is the founder of Colorado Food Reviews. He travels the state uncovering small-town legends, local favorites, and overlooked holes in the wall. His writing isn’t fluff—it’s fire-roasted truth with a splash of green chile.
Want to See Your Spot Featured?
Got a pizza joint in Fort Collins (or anywhere in Colorado) that deserves a spotlight? We want to hear about it. Drop us a line at submit@coloradofoodreviews.com—and if David’s hungry, he’ll be there with napkins in hand and notes on deck. David knows what the best pizza in fort collins is but if you want to challenge him submit your pick.
Join the Pizza Hunt
Colorado Food Reviews is rolling deep—town to town, crust to crust. Bookmark us and ride along. We’re always hungry for the next big flavor. Got suggestions for the best pizza in Fort Collins? Send them our way, and we might just put them to the test.
