Fort Collins is known for its great beer, but the Mayor of Old Town Fort Collins is the place to go if you want to drink beer and meet people. The Mayor has become more than just a beer bar; with 100 rotating beers on tap, a full-service menu that is much better than typical bar food, and a huge patio that is dog-friendly, it is now a key part of the city’s downtown identity.
Regulars call it “The Mayor,” and it’s consistently one of the best beer bars in Fort Collins because it cares so much about variety, flavor, and community. This is the kind of place that delivers, whether you’re looking for a limited-release IPA or just want to hang out with friends and eat truffle fries.
We read more than 400 real trustworthy reviews from Yelp, TripAdvisor, BeerAdvocate, and Untappd to find out real experience what people in Old Town really think about the Mayor. The decision? It’s a must-see place, especially if you love beer and want to eat out without sacrificing quality.
Updated May 2025
Table of Contents
You may also like reading about
About Mayor of Old Town Fort Collins: Location, Hours & Layout
Address: 632 S Mason St, Fort Collins, CO 80524
Phone: (970) 682-2410
Website: themayorofoldtown.com
Menu: View Full Food Menu
Yelp Profile: Mayor of Old Town on Yelp
Located just steps from CSU and right off the MAX transit line, the Mayor of Old Town Fort Collins CO sits in the heart of downtown, nestled between local shops, music venues, and other standout eateries. It’s an easy choice for lunch meetups, post-class beers, or late-night bites.
Operating Hours:
- Mon–Thu: 12:00 PM – 10:00 PM
- Fri–Sat: 12:00 PM – 11:00 PM
- Sunday: 12:00 PM – 10:00 PM
Tip from a local: “Weekends can get busy, but the vibe stays relaxed—and the staff handles the crowd like pros.”
There’s ample indoor seating anchored by a modern-industrial bar, plus a large outdoor patio that’s a favorite for pet owners and sunseekers. The dog-friendly space is one of the Mayor’s unsung features, giving it extra pull during spring and summer months.
While the venue doesn’t take reservations, wait times are usually minimal—though they may creep up during weekend rushes and major tapping events.
🍻 The Mayor’s Beer Program Is the Stuff of Legend
At the heart of the Mayor of Old Town Fort Collins experience is its legendary beer selection. With 100 beers on tap, this place easily ranks among the top craft beer destinations in Northern Colorado—if not the entire state.
“You will not find a better beer lineup in Fort Collins. From sours to stouts, they cover it all.” —BeerAdvocate user
The tap list rotates constantly and includes:
- Local Colorado brews from breweries like Odell, Funkwerks, and New Belgium
- National craft favorites like Dogfish Head, Bell’s, and Russian River
- International imports including Belgians, German lagers, and English ales
- Seasonal releases and collab beers that showcase regional creativity
There’s a chalkboard-style tap wall that outlines each pour’s origin, style, and ABV—plus staff who actually know their way around a flight. Whether you’re a certified cicerone or a casual sipper, the beer program is built to impress without overwhelming.
The Mayor also regularly partners with local breweries for events and special tappings. While specific collabs vary, their commitment to Fort Collins’ thriving beer scene is evident—and reviewers appreciate the authenticity.
From Untappd: “Feels like a rotating beer festival you can walk into any day of the week.”
🍽️ The Mayor of Old Town Food Menu: What Locals Crave
While beer might be the headline, the Mayor of Old Town Fort Collins has built a strong reputation for offering elevated bar food that actually holds its own. More than one reviewer has noted that they came for the taps—but stayed for the food.
This isn’t the kind of place where food plays second fiddle to the drinks. Instead, the kitchen puts out comfort-focused, flavor-driven dishes that make The Mayor a top pick for casual diners in Fort Collins looking to pair serious beer with satisfying bites.
“It’s the first place I think of when someone asks where to eat in Old Town. That truffle fry aroma gets me every time.” —Yelp reviewer
🔥 What’s on the Menu?
The Mayer of Old Town food menu has a good mix of appetizers, main courses, and sides that will please both meat eaters and vegetarians. There are a lot of different types of food, from spicy tacos to hearty burgers, and many of them come with house-made sauces or local ingredients.
Price range: Most entrées fall between $10–$19, making this a moderately priced spot where quality exceeds expectations.
You can find plenty of options no matter how hungry you are ranging from simple appetizers to full entrees. Read the full menu below.
📄 View the full food menu here
🧀 Customer Favorites That Locals Swear By
These are the things that Yelp, TripAdvisor, and local forums always talk about the most. If you’re just grabbing a quick lunch or settling in for a long evening, these are the dishes that are most likely to win you over.
🍔 Mayor Burger
A juicy house favorite topped with cheese, red onion, lettuce, tomato, and their signature secret sauce. Served with a crisp pickle spear on the side.
“Best burger in downtown Fort Collins—especially with a hoppy IPA.” —TripAdvisor
🍟 Parmesan Truffle Fries
Golden fries tossed in truffle oil and shaved Parmesan. Universally loved for their richness and aroma.
“Get them. Trust me. These are the reason I keep coming back to the Mayor of Old Town Fort Collins.” —Google review
🐟 Fish & Chips
Beer-battered cod served with house-made tartar sauce and crispy fries. A crunchy, satisfying classic.
🌶️ Buffalo Cauliflower
Crispy, battered florets with a tangy kick. Served with dipping sauce. A must-try for vegetarians and wing lovers alike.
🥓 Stuffed Dates
Sweet and savory—these bacon-wrapped, cheese-stuffed dates are a hit for sharable starters or small plates with drinks.
🌮 Mini Chicken Tacos
Packed with seasoned shredded chicken and balanced with toppings. Perfect with a pale ale or a crisp lager.
🥨 Fresh Salted Pretzel
Soft-baked pretzel served with a black and tan beer cheese sauce and German mustard. Rich, dippable, and a craft beer essential.
Read Paul H.‘s review of The Mayor of Old Town on Yelp“This is why it’s more than just a beer place. The food’s legit.” —Yelp
🥦 Vegetarian Options at The Mayor of Old Town Fort Collins
Don’t let the word “burger” dominate your expectations—the Mayor of Old Town Fort Collins makes space for vegetarians too. The buffalo cauliflower, pretzels, and Parmesan truffle fries are all vegetarian, and the menu often includes specials that cater to plant-based diets.
While it’s not a strictly vegetarian restaurant, flexibility is built in. Many items can be modified, and staff are typically accommodating when it comes to dietary requests.
From a HappyCow user: “I was surprised how easy it was to eat here. The staff had no problem making changes so I could skip dairy.”
🌱 Menu Flexibility Highlights:
- Sub cheese or sauce on burgers/sandwiches
- Buffalo cauliflower is vegetarian by default
- Pretzels and fries can be paired with mustard or served plain
This attention to diverse palates helps the Mayor of Old Town Fort Collins appeal to larger groups—especially when half the table wants burgers and the other half wants lighter fare.
🍴 A Dining Experience That’s More Than an Afterthought
Across reviews, one recurring sentiment is that the food isn’t just there to support the beer—it’s actually a draw in itself.
“You could take the beer away and I’d still eat here weekly. The food’s that good.” —Google reviewer
And with the kitchen open all day from noon until close, you’ll rarely find yourself out of luck for a meal, whether you’re popping in for an early lunch or arriving fashionably late after a CSU game or Old Town event.
🎶 Lively Vibes, Local Soundtracks & a Patio That Pops
If you ask Fort Collins locals what sets the Mayor of Old Town Fort Collins apart from other bars or taprooms in town, the answer usually goes beyond the beer list. It’s the vibe. The atmosphere. The balance between energy and comfort, especially when the patio is packed and there’s music playing.
🏙️ Atmosphere: Where Industrial Meets Inviting
Inside, the Mayor channels an industrial-chic design that feels modern without being cold. Exposed brick, reclaimed wood, and steel accents give the space a contemporary look that still feels grounded in Colorado’s casual, welcoming spirit.
“It’s that perfect mix—laid-back but still polished. You can show up in jeans or bring your out-of-town parents here.” —Yelp reviewer
The full-service layout means you’re seated and served—no jostling at the bar or waiting awkwardly to order. This gives the Mayor a more elevated dining feel compared to typical beer halls or taprooms.
☀️ The Outdoor Patio: Dog-Friendly, Crowd-Approved
Arguably one of the Mayor’s best-kept secrets is its spacious outdoor patio, which is both pet-friendly and well-shaded. Whether you’re bringing a dog, meeting up with friends, or just want to enjoy a beer in the sun, the patio often feels like an extension of Fort Collins itself—relaxed, social, and full of character.
“They brought our dog a bowl of water before we even asked. That’s how you win people over.” —TripAdvisor
The patio hosts small groups comfortably and is often the preferred spot on weekends or during warm-weather months. This added layer of outdoor space helps the Mayor of Old Town Fort Collins stand out in a city where patios matter just as much as pint glasses.
🎤 Live Music, Tap Takeovers & Event Energy
While it’s not a full-scale concert venue, live music at the Mayor of Old Town Fort Collins is a regular and highly anticipated feature. Smaller acoustic sets, local bands, and DJ nights bring added energy—especially on Fridays and Saturdays.
In addition to music, the Mayor regularly hosts:
- Tap Takeovers with local and regional breweries
- Themed Events (e.g., IPA challenges, stout showcases)
- Special Beer Releases with limited pours
- Fundraisers and Community Events tied to Fort Collins causes
These happenings are usually promoted via Instagram or Facebook, and many locals follow the bar just to catch the next rare tapping or patio show.
“I once stumbled into a sour beer night and ended up staying for three hours. They always have something going on.” —BeerAdvocate reviewer
💬 What the Vibe Means to Fort Collins
In many ways, the Mayor of Old Town Fort Collins feels like a cultural snapshot of the city itself. It reflects what Fort Collins residents value—good beer, easygoing social spaces, local music, dog-friendly patios, and elevated but unfussy food.
Whether you’re here for a quick pint, a group dinner, or a full-on weekend hangout, it’s the combination of factors—beer, bites, and vibe—that keeps the Mayor on everyone’s shortlist.
“We’ve made it our Friday spot. It’s kind of our tradition now.” —Local Google review
💬 The Reviews: The Verdict from 400+ Locals
With over 430 reviews and a 4.4-star average on Yelp, it’s clear that the Mayor of Old Town Fort Collins has earned its place as a go-to in the city’s dining and drinking landscape.
Across platforms like TripAdvisor, BeerAdvocate, and Untappd, locals repeatedly praise three key elements:
- The unbeatable beer variety
- The consistency of the food
- The friendly, attentive service
⭐ What Locals Say About The Mayor of Old Town
Read Amy S.‘s review of The Mayor of Old Town on Yelp Read Hannah S.‘s review of The Mayor of Old Town on Yelp Read Rosi D.‘s review of The Mayor of Old Town on YelpWhile a few reviews mention noise levels during peak hours, the sentiment is overwhelmingly positive. The Mayor of Old Town Fort Collins is widely seen as worth visiting—for first-timers and regulars alike.
📊 How It Compares: Craft Bar Icons in Fort Collins
Fort Collins is a craft beer capital, and with that comes competition. Here’s how The Mayor of Old Town Fort Collins stacks up against two of its most notable neighbors.
🍺 Tap and Handle
- Taps: 74
- Vibe: Smaller, taproom-focused
- Food: Limited, mostly small bites
Great for: Beer-first, food-optional visits
🥩 Choice City Butcher & Deli
- Taps: ~35
- Vibe: Food-forward with deli roots
- Food: Sandwiches and specialty meats
Great for: Serious foodies, brunch and lunch crowds
🏆 Mayor of Old Town
- Taps: 100
- Vibe: Balanced beer + food + social space
- Food: Full menu with standouts like the Mayor Burger, fish & chips, and stuffed dates
Best for: Beer lovers who want food that matters—and a place to linger
“Tap and Handle is where I go for rare beers. The Mayor is where I go when I want a full evening out.” —Reddit user
❓FAQ: What You Should Know Before Visiting the Mayor of Old Town Fort Collins
Where is The Mayor of Old Town located?
632 S Mason St, Fort Collins, CO 80524, just south of CSU and easily walkable from Old Town Square.
Does The Mayor of Old Town take reservations?
No. The Mayor of Old Town Fort Collins operates on a first-come, first-served basis. Wait times are minimal except during peak evenings or event nights.
Is the patio dog-friendly?
Yes. The outdoor patio is fully dog-friendly, shaded, and often hosts groups with pets—water bowls included.
What are the hours?
- Mon–Thu: 12 PM – 10 PM
- Fri–Sat: 12 PM – 11 PM
- Sunday: 12 PM – 10 PM
Is there parking near the Mayor of Old Town?
Yes, but it’s street parking only. Arrive early on weekends or use nearby city lots.
What’s the most popular dish?
The Mayor Burger and Parmesan Truffle Fries lead the pack. For starters, the Stuffed Dates and Buffalo Cauliflower get consistent praise.
Is The Mayor of Old Town good for vegetarians?
Yes—vegetarian options are available, and many dishes can be modified. The menu includes meat-free starters, sides, and custom-friendly mains.
Is it worth visiting if I’m not a big beer drinker?
Definitely. While it’s known for its tap list, The Mayor of Old Town Fort Collins also offers cocktails, wine, and non-alcoholic options. The food and vibe stand on their own.
Why The Mayor of Old Town Still Reigns in Fort Collins
There’s a reason they continues to top lists of the best bars, patios, and casual dining spots in the city. It offers more than quantity—it delivers consistency, comfort, and a sense of place. This isn’t just a stop on a brewery crawl. It’s a destination.
With 100 rotating taps, a crowd-pleasing food menu, and an environment that works for everything from after-work drinks to Saturday lunch, The Mayor of Old Town Fort Collins Colorado proves that craft beer and community go hand in hand.
So whether you’re a longtime local or just passing through Fort Collins, grab a seat on the patio, order something bold, and let The Mayor remind you what makes this city taste so good.
🖋️ About the Author
Written by David Lanketh, a Colorado-based food and beverage writer specializing in regional craft beer culture, dining experiences, and hospitality trends across the Front Range. View David’s profile here.
📰 About us
Colorado Food Reviews curates reliable, community-backed insights into the state’s best dining and drinking spots—from beer-forward taprooms to brunch hideaways. No fluff, no fakery—just honest local guides. Read more about us and our editorial policy here.
We curate all of our information from trustworthy public sources like yelp, trip advisor, social media, google reviews, and other online sources. Our editors compile authoritative guides filled with local experience and expertise to help others find their new favorite bar or restaurant!
📣 Have a Fort Collins bar or beer joint we should know about?
Drop us a tip here. We’re always on the hunt for the next hidden gem.
