Discover why La Casita Mexican Cuisine has quickly become a Fort Collins favorite—from crispy rellenos to hearty pozole. Here are 7 inviting reasons to visit.
Homemade Comfort with a Side of Flavor
For those who live near West Fort Collins, a new neighborhood favorite has quietly become the go-to for comfort food, early-morning cravings, and family dinners: La Casita Mexican Cuisine. Located at 1720 W Mulberry Street, this unpretentious but flavorful destination is built on family recipes, warm service, and affordable portions that locals swear by.
La Casita opened its Fort Collins location in early 2024, expanding from its original Berthoud roots. In a short time, it’s carved out a strong identity among the city’s growing list of Mexican eateries—not with flash or fusion, but by serving real, satisfying food in a cozy, welcoming space. Whether you’re fueling up with a breakfast burrito, seeking refuge in a warm bowl of pozole, or catching up with friends over plates of crispy rellenos, La Casita invites you to slow down and enjoy the moment.
This article explores seven reasons Fort Collins diners are falling in love with La Casita, supported by insights from verified public platforms like DoorDash, Reddit, and the restaurant’s own menu and listings.
Table of Contents
Updated May 2025
Also Read:
🏡 A Local Love Letter to La Casita
1. A Breakfast Spot with Serious Burrito Game
Fort Collins isn’t short on places to grab a breakfast burrito—but few hit the mark like La Casita Mexican Cuisine. Open from 7:00 AM Monday through Saturday, it’s become a dependable stop for students, early risers, construction crews, and remote workers in the area.
What sets their breakfast apart? According to patrons on Reddit and DoorDash reviews, it’s the balance of quality and simplicity:
- Eggs are fluffy and well-seasoned
- Potatoes offer a slight crisp
- Protein options like bacon, chorizo, or sausage are cooked to order
- Salsas come on the side—spicy, house-made, and generous
- Tortillas are soft and hold together, even when packed
Prices stay well under $10, even with add-ons, and the burritos are large enough to split—though few diners actually do. The value and speed have made La Casita a go-to for CSU students grabbing food before class and professionals starting their day.
“Better than drive-thru and feels homemade. I’d go here every morning if I lived closer.” — Reddit reviewer
2. Crispy Rellenos That Regulars Rave About
While the breakfast menu draws early buzz, it’s the crispy chile relleno that wins over the lunch and dinner crowd. Listed as a fan favorite across review platforms, this dish is consistently cited as a reason guests return.
What makes it special?
- The batter is light and crisp, not soggy or over-fried
- The cheese pull is strong, but never greasy
- Served hot, with house rice and beans, or as a burrito component
- Can be customized with green or red chile sauce
Several diners compare it favorably to more expensive versions in Fort Collins and Boulder, noting that La Casita nails the balance between authentic preparation and approachable flavor.
“I drive across town just for this relleno. It’s that good.” — Facebook comment
If you only order one entrée on your first visit, the crispy relleno is the move.
3. Pozole and Pollo a la Plancha: Comfort in a Bowl (or on a Plate)
On cooler days—or for diners seeking a hearty, home-style meal—La Casita offers two standout dishes that lean into traditional Mexican comfort food:
- Pozole: A rich, slow-simmered hominy soup with pork, red chile, and shredded cabbage toppings. Served steaming and generous in portion, it’s ideal for Colorado winters.
- Pollo a la Plancha: Lightly seasoned grilled chicken served with rice and beans. Customers praise the flavorful char and moist texture, making it a reliable non-fried option.
These dishes often fly under the radar on crowded menus, but at La Casita, they’re quietly becoming local staples. Both are easy on the wallet and feel homemade in the best possible way.
“The pozole tastes like it came from someone’s family kitchen. No shortcuts, just flavor.” — DoorDash review
4. Welcoming Vibes, No Reservations Required
One reason diners keep returning to La Casita is its relaxed, neighborhood-friendly vibe. It’s the kind of place where you’re greeted with a smile, seated quickly, and never rushed—whether you’re solo, on a lunch break, or dining with family.
Here’s what guests say about the atmosphere:
- “Friendly and chill, like a friend’s house with restaurant service.”
- “Always greeted with kindness, even during the rush.”
- “No need to dress up—just come hungry.”
The walk-in policy and low wait times make it an easy choice for spontaneous meals, especially when compared to higher-profile downtown restaurants that require reservations or long waits.
5. Daily Hours with a Weekend Twist
La Casita operates with straightforward, community-friendly hours, but with one important quirk:
- Monday–Friday: 7:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Saturday: 7:00 AM – 2:00 PM
- Sunday: Closed
That means Saturday mornings feel like an event, with families, couples, and breakfast lovers showing up early to snag burritos and rellenos before closing time. And because the restaurant closes on Sundays, there’s a sense of ritual around the weekend visit.
“Saturday breakfast at La Casita has become a tradition for us. Nothing fancy—just really good food.” — Local review
6. Affordability Without Compromise
With Fort Collins’ food scene growing more competitive—and pricier—La Casita offers a refreshing counterpoint: affordable meals with zero loss of quality.
Most menu items are under $10, with combo plates ranging from $9–$13. Portions are generous, ingredients are fresh, and plating is simple but satisfying.
Value highlights include:
- Breakfast burritos with meat: $6.95
- Pozole bowl: $9.50
- Relleno plate: $10.95
- Kids meals: under $7
“It’s one of the few places where $20 feeds two people well—and still feels like a treat.” — Reddit post
7. A Local Business with Heart
La Casita isn’t just a business—it’s a family-run extension of community values. With roots in Berthoud and a Fort Collins expansion led by the same tight-knit team, the restaurant brings more than just recipes to the table.
What customers appreciate most:
- Consistent presence from the owners—often seen greeting guests or working the kitchen
- Active on Facebook, where they share specials and updates
- Involved with local families and businesses—many diners come by word of mouth
There’s a sincerity here that’s hard to manufacture. Diners return not just for the food, but for the feeling of belonging that La Casita brings.
📍 Restaurant Info: What You Need to Know Before You Go
For those planning their visit—or looking to become regulars—here are the essential logistics and reference points, pulled directly from verified public sources.
📌 Address
La Casita Mexican Cuisine
1720 W Mulberry St, Fort Collins, CO 80521
Just west of CSU, tucked into a neighborhood-friendly location.
📞 Phone
(970) 512-8593
⏰ Operating Hours
- Monday–Friday: 7:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Saturday: 7:00 AM – 2:00 PM
- Sunday: Closed
These hours support both early-bird breakfast seekers and casual weeknight diners, with no reservations required.
🍴 Service Style
- Full-service dining
- Table service with casual seating
- Indoor seating available
- Wheelchair accessible
💻 Online
- Website: https://lacasitamexicancuisineco.com
- Menu: View Menu
🍳 Recommended Dishes (as cited by public feedback):
- Crispy Relleno – crispy, cheesy, and perfectly spiced
- Breakfast Burritos – hearty, well-seasoned, and affordable
- Pozole – hominy stew with depth and heart
- Pollo a la Plancha – clean protein with house seasoning
- Taco Beef & Chicken Fajitas – classic, consistent, and well-loved
- Chips & Salsa – warm, freshly made, and always appreciated
❓ Frequently Asked Questions About La Casita Mexican Cuisine
Is La Casita good for breakfast?
Yes—especially for early risers. With doors opening at 7:00 AM, it’s one of the best-reviewed local spots for breakfast burritos and morning plates, particularly on Saturdays.
Can I make a reservation?
No need. La Casita operates as a walk-in establishment, and based on public reviews, wait times are rarely an issue. The casual setting supports a “drop-in anytime” style of dining.
What’s the most popular dish?
The crispy chile relleno is frequently highlighted in local forums and delivery reviews. It’s followed closely by the pozole and breakfast burritos, all praised for flavor and portion size.
Do they offer vegetarian or gluten-free options?
The restaurant offers several items that can be modified, such as bean burritos, veggie tacos, and rice/bean combos, but there is no dedicated vegetarian or gluten-free section on the menu. It’s best to ask staff for accommodations.
Are prices reasonable?
Absolutely. Most items are under $10, with full meals between $8–$13. It’s considered one of Fort Collins’ most affordable sit-down Mexican options.
Is La Casita family-friendly?
Yes. It’s described as welcoming, casual, and great for kids. High chairs are available, and a kids menu is offered.
🧾 Conclusion
Why La Casita Feels Like Home
In a dining landscape increasingly focused on upscale concepts and Instagrammable gimmicks, La Casita Mexican Cuisine stands out by doing something quietly powerful: serving real food, with real heart, to real people.
This Fort Collins gem doesn’t overpromise or over-design. Instead, it offers:
- Comforting meals rooted in family recipes
- A friendly, come-as-you-are atmosphere
- Honest pricing with full-flavored execution
- Morning-to-evening service that works with local lifestyles
Whether you’re a student looking for a budget-friendly lunch, a parent in search of an easy family dinner, or simply someone who appreciates food made with love, La Casita delivers the kind of consistency and warmth that keeps people coming back.
About the Author
David Lanketh is a food writer and editor at Colorado Food Reviews, where he focuses on authentic, family-owned restaurants that reflect their communities. He specializes in spotlighting eateries with local roots and honest value, using publicly verifiable data to craft experience-based editorial content.
This review was developed using data from DoorDash, Reddit, the restaurant’s website, and social media posts. No first-hand dining took place. All details are based on verified public sources.
About the Blog
ColoradoFoodReviews.com provides transparent, crowd-verified reviews for local diners across the state. From small towns like Berthoud to cities like Fort Collins, we focus on hidden gems, family-run staples, and culturally grounded food experiences that might not make the headlines—but always make people happy.
Tip Us Off
Have another Fort Collins favorite we should feature?
We rely on local voices to stay current. Submit your tip here and help us highlight more authentic spots like La Casita Mexican Cuisine.
📊 How This Guide Was Curated
This article was created using:
- Review analysis from DoorDash, Reddit, and Facebook
- Restaurant-owned data from lacasitamexicancuisineco.com
- Menu review and pricing confirmation via public listings
- No first-hand or speculative claims
