Address: 125 S College Ave (above Japango), Fort Collins, CO 80524
Phone: (970) 413‑7435
Yelp Rating: 3.5 ★ from ~16 reviews
Sugar Salt Sand Meets Downtown Fort Collins
Old Town Fort Collins isn’t exactly where you’d expect to find a tropical rooftop tiki bar, but Sugar Salt Sand defies the norm—and that’s the whole point. Opened in April 2025 by the team behind Japango, this vibrant upstairs spot was designed as a playful oasis. From hanging swing benches and tiki cocktails to poke bowls and conch fritters, Sugar Salt Sand offers a taste of the beach without leaving the city.
It’s one of the most visually distinct and atmospherically creative venues in Fort Collins right now, making it a must-visit for locals chasing a mini-vacation and visitors looking for something memorable. While the vibe is dialed in, early diners note that the food and service are still catching up to the décor.
Table of Contents
Atmosphere & Dining Experience
Step through Japango and upstairs to a transformed rooftop that feels miles away from Colorado. Rattan swings, oversized plants, and twinkle lights surround lounge-style tables, setting a tone that’s breezy, eclectic, and unmistakably tropical. Reviews describe it as “a resort bar dropped into Old Town” and “a little slice of Mexico or Florida on College Ave.”
The dress code leans resort-casual, and the vibe ranges from laid-back during brunch to lively in the evening. Whether you’re sipping a Hemingway Daiquiri in a sunhat or diving into ceviche with friends, the rooftop design fosters a light, social energy unlike anything else in the area.
What to Order at Sugar Salt Sand
The kitchen leans coastal—expect poke, ceviche, tacos, and fried rice alongside Caribbean-style apps and tropical cocktails. Early favorites focus more on seafood and bar snacks than heavy entrees.
Based on our research, locals love the following:
- Traditional Ahi Poke & Spicy Mayo Poke (Ahi or Salmon)
Priced at $15, these bowls feature fresh fish with flavor-forward marinades. The spicy mayo variant adds a satisfying heat. - Turks & Baja Ceviche
A citrusy, shareable dish with bright acidity—frequently ordered as a starter. - Conch Fritters
A nod to Caribbean street food, praised for texture and flavor. One of the more unique offerings in Fort Collins. - Fish & Chips
Often cited on Reddit and MapQuest reviews as a “surprising standout”—crispy, flaky, and well-portioned. - Fried Rice
Not traditional tiki fare, but loved for its seasoning and heartiness. A vegetarian-friendly favorite. - Al Pastor & Fish Tacos
Street-style, priced around $5.50–$6.50 per taco. Both praised for flavor, though some reviews cite portion size as modest.
Cocktail Program
Where Sugar Salt Sand shines brightest is the bar program. Tiki cocktails are central to the experience, with a rotating menu of house originals and island classics.
Top picks include:
- Mai Tai
A well-balanced version that blends rum depth with citrus pop. Widely recommended. - Hemingway Daiquiri
Light and refreshing—easy to drink, hard to stop at one. - Jungle Bird
A bitter-leaning cocktail for those who want complexity. - Nutty by Nature
A playful, nutty coconut-based sipper. - Billy Bones
Stronger and darker, for those who prefer rum-forward profiles.
Cocktails are priced around $10.50 and are frequently praised for their quality, especially compared to similar concepts. According to multiple Reddit users, “worth every penny.”
Menu Overview & Pricing
Sugar Salt Sand’s food menu rotates with seasonal tweaks, but staples include:
- Fish Market: Poke, ceviche, oysters when available
- Appetizers: Conch fritters, Hurricane Popcorn, Iniki Fries
- Entrees: Fish & chips, fried rice, scampi, tacos
- Flatbreads and salads round out lighter fare
- Pricing:
- Apps: ~$6–$13
- Poke & Ceviche: ~$15
- Entrees: ~$13–$30
- Cocktails: ~$10.50
Dietary accommodations are available, with vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free items clearly marked. There is no dedicated kids menu, but tacos and fries are approachable for younger eaters.
Operating Hours & Seating
- Mon–Fri: 11 AM–10 PM
- Sat–Sun:
- Brunch: 10 AM–2 PM
- “Siesta” (Limited Menu): 2–4 PM
- Dinner: 4–10 PM
Reservations via OpenTable are encouraged—especially on weekends—but walk-ins are accepted. Seating includes standard tables, bar seating, and swings. The space is elevated, so wheelchair access via Japango’s ground entry may be needed for rooftop elevator access.
Customer Feedback: Praise & Critiques
What people love:
- “Feels like you’re on vacation—great drinks, killer vibe.”
- “Food was fresh, drinks were strong, and it’s gorgeous.”
- “Nothing else like it in Northern Colorado.”
What people want improved:
- Service speed during busy times—multiple guests cite 30-minute waits for drinks.
- Portion sizes on some dishes (particularly tacos) were described as “underwhelming for the price.”
- Some mixed feedback on “style over substance,” though many acknowledge it’s early days for the venue.
Who It’s For
Sugar Salt Sand caters to:
- Young professionals and creatives
- College students and grads
- Brunch seekers and cocktail lovers
- Locals looking for something visually fun and vacation-inspired
- Groups and rooftop date nights
This isn’t your spot for quiet conversation or serious foodies chasing precision—this is about ambiance, drinks, and sun-soaked fun.
Community Presence & Brand Culture
Part of the Fort Collins Beach Club concept, Sugar Salt Sand positions itself as more than a restaurant. It’s a destination, with potential for future events, beach club memberships, and themed parties.
The venue has active social media, particularly on Instagram, where its colorful decor, drinks, and rooftop swings feature prominently. While no clear sustainability practices are listed, the laid-back brand tone aligns with local lifestyle and leisure.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Sugar Salt Sand family-friendly?
It’s primarily geared toward adults, but the casual menu works for older kids. No kids’ menu is listed.
Can I bring my dog?
The rooftop likely allows pets, though it’s not officially stated—best to call ahead if you’re unsure.
What’s the best time to visit?
For relaxed dining, come early evening or during brunch hours. Peak times (7–9 PM weekends) can get crowded.
Is there live music or events?
Not yet, but future events are hinted at through the Beach Club membership and social media promotions.
Do I need a reservation?
Reservations via OpenTable are recommended, especially for weekends and dinner.
Conclusion: Fort Collins’ Tiki Rooftop with Personality
Sugar Salt Sand is a bold, tropical statement in the heart of Old Town—a place where Fort Collins meets the beach. With its playful design, island-inspired menu, and craft cocktails, it offers a welcome escape from the everyday. While the food and service still have room to grow, the concept is ambitious and fun, making it one of the city’s most talked-about new openings. If you’re in search of cocktails with character and a rooftop vibe, this is your next stop.
About the Author
Written by Jordan Rae, an editor at Colorado Food Reviews who curates culinary guides based on verified public consensus across thousands of online reviews.
About Colorado Food Reviews
Colorado Food Reviews is a regional editorial guide spotlighting the most noteworthy food experiences across the Front Range. We aggregate insights from thousands of diners and publish researched, trust-based restaurant reviews.
Submit a Spot
Know a place we should review next? Submit a Spot to help us uncover Colorado’s hidden dining gems.
